advertisement

The world-famous Internet site of the Nationally Syndicated Neal Boortz Show!

Search Boortz.com
Enter search terms:
Browse Boortz.com
Today's Nuze

"Every government interference in the economy consists of giving an unearned benefit, extorted by force, to some men at the expense of others."

Ayn Rand

Nobody's listening.

MICHELLE SAYS TO GIVE BACK

By
Neal Boortz
@ May 18, 2009 8:27 AM
Permalink | Comments (108) | TrackBacks (0)

It's graduation time, and everyone was invited to give a commencement speech .. except me, of course. I've never been invited to give my commencement speech. I did deliver a high school commencement speech once, and enjoyed it. No negative critiques either. But a college or university? You have to be kidding me. Ain't gonna happen. We will have the chance this week to get some inkling of what I might do, however. I'm going to be delivering a faux commencement speech this Wednesday evening Kennesaw State University. That's about as close as it's gonna get for now.

Let's get to the people who do get to speak to graduates ... Michelle Obama gave the commencement address at UC Merced over the weekend. In her speech, she told the students to do one of my absolute favorite things: give back.

Gag.

She says, "You will face tough times. You will certainly have doubts, and let me tell you because I know I did when I was your age ... Remember that you are blessed. Remember that in exchange for those blessings, you must give something back. You must reach back and pull someone up. You must bend down and let someone else stand on your shoulders so that they can see a brighter future."

Sometimes I think I'm alone here, but this "give back" crap just makes me nuts. It is now the standard language of the left and those who should know better use the phrase all the time.

OK ... here we go again: The inference in the "give back" phrase is that whatever you have was given to you. You graduates have had this education handed to you on a silver platter. You didn't earn it. You didn't study. You didn't stay up long hours trying to understand a difficult text or to study for a critical exam. You didn't spend evenings in study groups that you could have spent brandishing your fake ID at several local watering holes. You romped and played your way through college and these diplomas you will received today will be given to you, not earned. Once you leave this college you will be given a job. You will not have earned that job through your educational pursuits, it will be given to you. Then, after you begin work, you will be given a salary. You will not have earned that money. If you receive commissions those will have been given to you as well. A gift. Not something you have earned. Ditto for bonuses. All gifts. Nothing earned through the application of skill and sweat.

Michelle Obama, and every other looter who has an eye on the wealth you produce, and who uses this "give back" line, will be completely negating every amount of effort you have put into your livelihood. Remember, they're not asking you to "give," they're telling you to "give back." The very premise of that phrase is that your wealth was a gift, not earned. Since your wealth was given to you, when you make some sort of a donation to a charity you are not "giving," you are "giving back."

I know that I drone on and on about this ... but this "give back" nonsense is like a dripping faucet.



0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: MICHELLE SAYS TO GIVE BACK.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://boortz.com/blogging/mt-tb.cgi/31206

Jamie Dupree's Blog

If you enjoy Neal's daily chat with Jamie Dupree, you'll love Jamie's Blog! Check it out for analysis of the campaigns and goings on in Washington D.C.

Cristina Gonzalez and Laura Nunemaker assist in the daily preparation of Nealz Nuze!


Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • michelle the malicious
    Folks, don't dignify an answer to copyleft. She's always on, just being french.....ha...ha you know....sociaolist. Just ignore her, she'll be beside herself if she can't get a response to her stupidity. She can give back.....since she obviously never earned anything. Most probably a parasitical welfare brood mare, using her kids as her meal ticket. Thieves need to convince us that we owe them their booty. Jamsey Comes Looking....American Indian Female
  • Giving back
    Cali-fornia gave it back to the Obama/Michele Admin. after her speech(which in my opinion was to rally the troops to pass the massive tax increase this week) they voted no on 6 taxes this week. That's what the voters think of her speech. There ya' go. NO
  • Giving Back
    Michelle's husband has taken trillions from us, and has obligated us to pay it back to China or whatever, and I don't remember us giving him or anyone else our consent to do so (does anyone remember being asked to co-sign these loans?). Where the hell does she and her husband, and myriad other looting trolls get off telling us to "give back" when so much has been stolen from us by the very parasites who lecture us?
  • re Mark
    Forget him, he's a total idiot that hides behind a facade of superiority, snide comments and sarcasm.
    That's what happens when you KNOW you are a pos.
    As for one example of govt abuse, actually, after 10 years I have hundreds, hundreds.
  • Mark answer my question
    What help did you receive that you feel the need to "give back"?

    "understood by most adults", there a liberal goes again ASSuming they know what most Americans are thinking.

    I am human, and I help people. At my choosing. But I don't owe anyone anything. I may have had some help from my Mother but she has had her thanks.

    MO and people like you give the impression, correct me if I'm wrong, that society has helped me in some way. Tell me how? Give me an example.
  • re:joyce
    Joyce,

    I'm gonna take a leap of faith and assume (maybe incorrectly) that you are a human being. And, that you are alive. Given those to assumptions being correct (again, could be wrong), you've had help getting where you are. But, what kind of help I have no idea. Which is why I said "it's up to you" because, I am sure there are people out there that didn't get that same help for a variety of reasons. And, if you're smart enough to recognize the kind of help you got, the humility you gain from that would hopefully enlighten you as to what it means to give back and illuminate the "what" you might want to look at giving.

    I'm sorry that this needs to be explained to you. Thankfully, it's already understood by most adults. But, if you truly feel you have nothing to give back and arrived at your station in life without help from anyone ever...I have nothing else I can say to you. Good luck to you in your life.
  • Mark
    Do you know me? Do you know what I've gone through and done to get here? No you don't. So I believe it is you who are being arrogant.

    Tell me, what should I "give back" for? What would society have done for me? You can answer the same question I posed for Copy: what do you have to give back for?
  • re:legion
    OMG, you have an example of abuse of a govt program!?!!?

    OMG, SHUT IT DOWN!! SHUT IT DOWN!!!!!

    That was close. You're my hero.

    Who said you're being forced? Oh right - I pay my taxes so I don't have to give? Isn't that the standard meme of republicans calling out democrats for not being MORE charitable?

    either way, not what anyone is talking about here but, thanks for playing!

    "jam it lib"? Seriously? heh....uh, good one Lesion
  • Copy didn't answer question
    "Tell me Copy, what did the community do for you, that you should give back? Give us an example?"
  • re:joyce
    LOL

    It's not arrogant to presume you arrived at where you are in life solely by yourself and without any help from anyone ever?

    yeeah...got me there! Touche!
  • Hey CopyLeft and Hypocrisy
    I'm a paramedic may I be opf assistance?
  • give back...ok
    Well the liberals gave me a shoddy education in public schools. I worked very hard for years to undo most of that and educate myself. I will give that back to them. When I was younger and needed help I applied for food stamps and was refused...hmmm. I pay my taxes, I pay my mortgage, I pay my credit cards and other bills. I support my family and help my friends. I open doors for others and say excuse me when I am in the way. However I work for my money and plan to keep all that I can for my own purposes.
    So as far as I can see there is little of any value this society has given to me so I have little to "give back" But I can understand Mrs Obama as she has undoubtedly been given much by society and should feel the need to pay some of it back. I wonder how much she does?
  • WHY
    WHY SHOULD WE "GIVE BACK"? IF OBAMA SAYS YOU SHOULD HELP OTHERS, let her get off her high horse, and do it herself. I'm
    sick of other people telling WHAT THEY THINK I SHOULD BE DOING.
  • Giving Back
    It's no technicality, "Giving" and "Giving Back" do have distinct meanings, and the Michelle Obamas of the world have a precise meaning: you belong to the greater society, so you owe that society big time. For those of us who don't feel like being "owned," we resent the notion og "giving back."
  • Hey Moron Mike!
    It IS socialism if we are FORCED to "give". I wouldn't mind keeping my taxes and deciding whom I want to give it to. I certainly don't feel like funding chinese prostitute studies, or finding out why gay men in Argentina get more promiscuous after they drink. Get off you high horse and shut the hell up. I've seen people on medicare, one I know works as a waitress 2 hours a day during lunch, has a house paid for by HUD, and just bought a new motorcycle and wants to buy a jetski...so jam it lib.
  • I hate the idea of "giving back"
    The whole idea of "giving back" is so asinine and it makes my blood boil every time I hear someone begging for someone to do so.

    To me, I define someone asking someone to "give back" or someone saying they are "giving back" is implying that they need to return something that wasn't theirs to begin with--as if they have stolen something and need to be made to feel guilty.

    Make no mistake, I will and have given many times to worthy causes but I promise you I will never "give back" because I haven't stolen anything and hell will freeze over before I let anyone guilt others into believing that I have.
  • Puke
    Yeah right...the Obamas have done nothing since winning the presidency except grab every thing their grubby little paws can get their hands on.
    Oh yeah I forgot the food shelter where she was wearing $500 shoes. Those two make me sick, and if I have to hear one more quip about how beautiful she is, what a great fashion sense blah blah blah...she is butt ugly and she needs more hair straightener. My suit costs less than her sneakers. Give back...yeah, it's easy for her to give back, she's using my TAXES!!!!!!!!! Oh, how much did the Obamas "Give back" to charity when it was THEIR money? Less than 5%?
  • Michelle Says to Give Back
    Look at Michelle Malkin's blog today. She reminds us how "generous" the Obamas have been in recent years giving a portion of their income to charity. They don't exactly practice what they preach.
  • Mark just like you said
    It's up to you.

    That is the point. And no, it isn't arrogant.
  • Flattery!
    Oh, look. More namejacking (at 2:39). Somebody's really getting desperate at having their opinions trounced with simple logic... (snicker)
  • Apparently UC Merced spent $700K
    to receive a lecture about "giving back" from the plunder-in-chief's wife.

    Never mind the money came from a capital improvement fund. That's democrap spending policy in full display. Spend what you don't have, borrow/steal from those who do.

    It used to be the Golden State. Now it's the junk-bond state.
  • so many morons in one place...
    Give, Give back...oy veh. Since when is such a simple concept lost on so many??

    Even if you work hard, to assume it's all you is arrogant. We all get by with a little help from someone. Be it family, friends, neighbors, co-workers, bosses, investors, etc. Sheesh...life aint this complicated people.

    Recognize that no man is an island and we all need a little help from time to time and you gain a very valuable thing - humility.

    from that grows the desire to take what you have (no matter how you got it) and help out someone who may need it. Whatever that means - advice, money, time, clothes...whatever. It's up to you.

    The point being made is - recognize that saying we're in this together is not socialism for crying out loud. have a little respect for the way the world works, grab a big bite of humble pie, quite your petty whining, and get to work.
  • Hmmm
    I guess I better shut up while I'm ahead!!! Thanks guys.

    Oh but one more thing (never was good at listening to my own advice), I was watching a video of an earlier politician, talking similiarly how it was the workers and not the companies who built this land, how they needed to rebuild for the workers and forget about the companies, how they would take everything back from the companies for the workers....

    I'm paraphrasing of course but even my slightly left husband got the similarity (I'm working on him). Anyone wanna guess who it was?
  • Can I get some of the giving...?
    This kind of talk is driving me crazy! I have worked very hard to get where I am and I enjoy a decent salary. How dare someone tell me that I need to "give back" and if I don't, they will just impose higher taxes. If this is the attitude of Washington, then what is the incentive for people to get educated and work hard? Heck, I might as well quit my job and let the goverment and the "rich" take care of me.
    My husband and I have made wise decisions with our finances and I am sick that we have to continue to pay for the mistakes of others. If we continue to get milked by all the bail outs, then I don't want to "give back" anymore. I would rather GIVE my money to charities that I enjoy and want to support. Don't MAKE me give back to stupid people.
  • Degree "Granted"
    The official looking paperwork that came with me degree stated that I had been "granted" my degree by the university muck-a-mucks. In other words, my 4.0 avg didn't earn it, they just found it in their hearts to give it to me at the end. Gee, thanks.
  • Joyce "Have to dumb this down"
    Right on the money! You are a much better communicator than I am!!!
  • re: Chuck
    Actually Chuck it looks like I put your name in incorrectly since I wasn’t reading and responding line by line to what was being written in the comments. I don’t feel the need to change, just the need to apologize to you for a rant you didn’t deserve though CopyLeft and Hypocrisy did.

    There are only three things I’m bitter about. First idiots like the Obamas telling me to change and give back, when there is nothing I need to change and I have nothing to give back since I never got anything from them in the first place. Second other idiots telling me that their religion is the ONLY way to go. Third and worst, the fact that these two groups seem to be the only ones that can get to D.C or the state capitals!

    Now the rant you do deserve. Do you even know what a Libertarian is? Try reading here: http://www.lp.org/platform Why the sarcasm? Nothing I said in that other post goes against what you will find in the libertarian platform. Well half a rant since I don’t see where you are coming from.

    There is one point of the platform I'm not sure I fully believe in, but I'd be willing to listen on the drug stance.
  • Giving Back
    I got a college education because of Berea College's alumni and the taxpayers who funded the Pell Grants. I am supremely grateful, and I work gratis for lots of organizations. I consider this an investment in my community, and a way of re-paying a perceived debt to people who helped me.

    Chris
  • Joyce v. Copytwit
    First of all, there is no competition here, because Joyce comes to the table with far more knowledge of the Constitution than Copytwit. Copytwit says that we are GIVEN our advantages, rights, and other things in life. Sorry moron, you clearly represent the socialist retards that devour the resources in this country every day. Per the Constitution, our rights are not given. They are automatically ours and even the government can not dictate how much of it is to be controlled. Figures, coming from a guy who rode the short bus to school and drooled on the window along the way.
  • @copyArse
    "We were simply lucky enough to be born here and have opportunities GIVEN to us that aren't available to 98% of the rest of the world."

    And please explain to me, Copy, how we've managed to ensure the freedoms of this great land of opportunity since our blessed forefathers who so valiantly fought for it? Do you think it might be by maintaining a military force full of hard-charging Americans who believe just as they did? Nah, we probably owe it to socialist-libs. Hey - maybe if we stock some of these "less-fortunate" third-world countries with leaders who think like you....hmm, then again there's that whole socio-facist-communism thing that's worked out about as well as a 600 pound woman on a treadmill..
  • Joyce M/Blythe and Copyleft
    Joyce - Right on! I couldn't agree more with you (on all posts). Copyleft will never understand. She (I am guessing no guy would write "(snicker)") has been given to her whole life. She has no job, no friends, no real contact with the outside world. Its easy to sit on her computer and point fingers at others. When I was younger, I much more liberal. Its easy to point out where you should give when you haven't had to earn it.
    Yes, I am lucky to have been born in this country, in this century. But so are the people that my tax dollars are going to support!
    Maybe one day Copyleft will have to grow up and become a productive member of society - make a house payment/rent, car payment, internet bill - then we'll see how much she gives back. Hey, Copyleft - don't forget insurance. There are plenty of losers like you who also don't believe in personal accountability and they think they deserve your money too.
  • Giving back
    Many years ago, when I was in my 20's, I was all for co-eds giving back, as long as it wasn't an STD.

    STD's: "The gift that keeps on giving."™
  • Sorry Alan
    I know you mean well, but I do think the distinction is important. As CJ put it, one assumes a repayment of a debt. If we don't fight these terms, we become automatons who think they owe everything to the government.

    I believe everyone should be charitable. But it should never be at the point of a government pen (gun).
  • And Another Thing
    And another thing.... do you know WHY this country is (or used to be, anyway) such a great place to be born? It's because of the free market system we used to have, that you so despise. We do not have a free market anymore, as there is too much government involvement and is the only cause for the economic meltdown we are in now...but we used to for a long time (Before FDR), and it is what made this country so great. It sure wasn't giving money to homeless people so they can buy alcohol! And it sure wasn't because of people like you, either, Copyleft. You are the type of people destroying this country.
  • Copyleft
    Copyleft, only one person makes my success possible and that is ME. It sure as heck isn't you! You clearly are only interested in mooching off other people's success, using your ridiculous "give back" argument for ...being born here! Great, I was lucky to be born here...guess that means I should give back to my parents maybe...but certainly not you and your brethren. You did absolutely nothing for me and my success. You are doing nothing for yours, either. Why should anyone "give back" ANYTHING to you?

    And yes, it's mine, I earned it, and I do say "screw you" if you don't want to do the same for yourself.

    What would be immoral would be giving you anything. You didn't earn it, you're a moocher, and keeping you alive is only an injustice to society.

    I really, really wish all the hardworking people would quit, just like in Atlas Shrugged, and let these worthless parasites like Copyleft die off. It's the only way I see this country getting back to its roots.
  • Libtards whining about Church giving now?
    These wouldn't be the same Libtards that sat back and said nothing when Rev. Wrong said "G_D D___M AMERICA!" would they?

    Ever notice how the only church/Rev. that the Libtards whine about is one tied to Conservatives? Finally, for the idiot below "Hypocrisy Detector" whining about the only charity going to churches, do these idiots not understand that church charity in many cases goes back to society through homeless and battered shelter setups? Do Libtards ever actually THINK at all? Guess not.
  • Values
    Copyleft's criticism of conservative values brings up an interesting contrast. First of all Republicans touted family values (and their faithfullness to those values is certainly questionable). Keep in mind that not all Republicans are really conservatives, and not all conservatives are Republicans (Boortz is a Libertarian). Still, let's explore the virtue involved in "giving back."

    "Giving back" assumes repayment for a debt. It assumes gratitude for something received or at least a feeling of obligation. That's exactly what Michelle Obama tried to imply. You have an OBLIGATION to give back.

    "Giving," however, does not assume a debt or obligation. While there may be a debt, the gift is not repayment of that debt.

    "Giving" is an act of love, compassion, or simple kindness. "Giving back" is an acknowledgement of a debt or obligation. With that in mind, is it any wonder that Big Government Liberals prefer to tout the idea of "Giving back" over "giving?" And which idea do you think is more virtuous?
  • Joyce, if I may
    She was merely preparing these individuals to become TAXPAYERS. That’s the sort of “giving back” she was referring to.

    Problem is, when she serves homeless people wearing $500 sneakers, we just can't hear what she's saying because her actions speak so much louder than her words.
  • words or message?
    Shouldn't we be focusing on the message?
    It seems to me that most everyone here is focused on the word choice. (Its these kind of petty arguments that are hurting the republicans.)

    I read someone arguing the technicalities of "giving" vs "giving back" ..

    You are creating a fake controversy.

    Give to your community if you want to ...
    Give back to your community if you want to ...
  • Have to dumb this down
    Ok, let's try it this way.

    GIVE --- this is a good thing that I think most American try to do when they can. It is a voluntary act. Money, or time donated to a worthy cause.

    GIVE BACK -- someone has previously given you something, maybe as in the above instance. At some point it would be nice if you pay them back. Or give to someone else in that first persons spirit of giving.

    Do ya understand the difference? Okay then.

    No one has given me anything. Except my mother.
  • O the humanity
    How dare she suggest we offer assistance to another human being?!?!The nerve on this women to suggest we help someone!!
  • I got mine
    So, copy, if everyone thought this way, i.e., "got theirs," what's the problem? No, the problem arises when someone say "I'm to stupid/lazy to get mine, so I'll use the police power of government to take yours."
  • Libtard definitions of givng back..
    "Giving back" in Libtard Land means that you do not work for a corporation that makes a profit; it means that you do NOT elevate yourself above someone else and make more than him/her; it means that if you DO make more than someone else (through your sacrifices in college while the slacker high school leftovers partied on weekends and never did more to better themselves; it means that you should NOT pursue life, liberty, and most importantly, the PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS.

    In Libtard Land, you are NOT allowed to be happy because others aren't "equal" to you. Who said Libtards were the true Conservatives and freedom lovers again? Oh yeah, moonbats like "Hugo's Ghost" and "Copyleft."
  • Ms. O's been giving, alright
    My guess is that Ms.O has the mindset that (being black), she has been "giving" all her life.

    ;-)
  • Copy
    Your earlier stoopid point was comparing how fortunate Americans are to the rest of the world. Are you skipping over that?

    Tell me Copy, what did the community do for you, that you should give back? Give us an example?
  • If you insist....
    The thugs, babymamas, and other assorted welfare trash may give my money back to me any time at all.
  • weird
    "Norman Radow, chairman of the KSU Foundation and CEO of Radco, a national real estate company that owns nearly $4 billion worth of property in 13 cities across the country." gave the commencement address for master's degree graduates and essentially said the same thing - give back.

    Wonder if Boortz will boycott KSU and not give his speech there? yeeah...didn't think so.
  • re:Tim
    So what are you angry about? I'm confused about what point you're trying to make. Don't throw your crap off on me, bro'. I give through Scouting, through charities and other ways that you will never hear about. I don't break my arm patting myself on the back. But don't lecture me or anyone else about the government giving to us and we having to give'back' in return. Hell, I'll even stick up for Copyleft on this one. You call yourself a Libertarian? Wow. You might need to rethink that before you give yourself the seal of approval. How about changing your attitude first, then your outlook on life. You are a really bitter man. Hope you change that for your own benefit.
  • Giving
    Gotta say it is a bothersome phrase, and I do find the "giving back" line abhorrent. The only people I will be giving back to once I graduate will be the institutions that provided me with the loans I used to go to school. Now, don't assume by my saying this that I don't give to charities, I do. I give my time and money to causes I believe in, but they gave me nothing, so there is no way I could "give back" to them.
  • Michele Obama
    Are these speeches M. Obama's idea of "giving back"? I smell the influence of Rev. Wright; "Live and do as I preach, not as I live and do."
  • @Copy
    Copy typed:"We were simply lucky enough to be born here and have opportunities GIVEN to us that aren't available to 98% of the rest of the world"

    Yeah, I was simply lucky to have served in both Gulf Wars in order to ensure that morons like CopyLeft are GIVEN the full benefits of being born here.

    Copy, I give you a "T" for trite and an "S" for self-absorbed. "TS", about what we can expect for a leftist.

    Now, if only we can arrange for a boatlift to Cuba to unload our leftist riff-raff.....
  • Kind of like serving homeless people in $500 sneakers
    I can’t hear what she's saying because her actions speak so much louder than her words.

    But in fairness, she and her idiot husband have the "taking" part down pat.
  • Tis better
    to give a HAND UP instead of a HAND OUT.
  • Stan and Copy
    Here's someone you can "give back" to.

    http://www.momoesmuse.blogspot.com/

    Come on, show us selfish folk how it's done!
  • Manure
    I've been on the bottom rung of the income ladder. This is to say, no job, no skills, a bum knee and living in my brother’s house. The government gave me nothing I hadn't earned (VA benefits for school in exchange for my service and that bum knee). The public gave me nothing period. I pushed through that to a degree with crap jobs, loans and family charity. I got a better job and paid my brother back by giving him a place to live when he needed it, he didn’t ask for payback. I paid back my loans and took out more to get another degree. I've moved up through my hard work and study, plus the help of my family when I was down.

    The government? They gave me nothing I didn't earn and have been a steady drain on those earnings to give handouts to people that make ZERO effort to move on to self sufficiency, drug dealers/users and trash moms that have kids for the handouts and something to whine about but ignore the kids otherwise.

    I give BACK what I'm given and when it comes to liberal government, I give and give and give and give with no return. When it comes to conservative government I give and give and get told I’m a nasty sinner because I think my gay friends should have rights and be treated fairly, and because I think a woman should be able to determine what goes on with her own body.

    Hypocrisy Detector, CopyLeft, Chuck - What have I been given by the government or liberal Dumbecrats? I say nothing. My primary education was paid by the school mileage on my parents property taxes. I paid for my associates through service in the Army and loans I paid back. I'm still paying on my BA loans. I haven't even received anything from the charities pushed by the Repulsivins. What EXACTLY do I need to "give BACK" for? What have you done to help me or people like me? You’ve given me nothing but self-righteous crap to read!

    The liberal pantywaists and conservative bible thumpers can both bite my butt! As long as we are stuck with two parties dominating our government we will get shafted! I can see the need to give people a hand up. I can see that government needs to be part of that hand up. But it has to be at the right level of government (Federal isn't it!), with the right oversight (Federal is far too remote!), and with safeguards against abuse (you make no effort to move on you stop getting anything).
  • $mooth
    The Obamas do have the taking part down. They took from the unions and now they are giving back!
  • To: Joyce
    "quit trying to sound like you are pointing out obvious things that everyone other than Neal can see."

    My apologies. I should've guessed that you don't see this obvious point either.

    Sure, "Americans" fought and died for our current privileges... OTHER Americans. Not you, and not me. We were simply lucky enough to be born here and have opportunities GIVEN to us that aren't available to 98% of the rest of the world.

    Time to give back. Unless you're a selfish, shortsighted fool, of course--as most libertarians basically are.
  • Jeff in Dayton, you are wrong
    You do Neal a GREAT dis-service by claiming he is giving back. All those wonderful things Neal contributes to, both in private, and those he touts on air, that's called "GIVING". Not "giving back". The only way for a person to "give back", would be to our Heavenly Father, who gave us life, soul, this world, every good blessing, even the air we breathe. And since all these still belong to Him, how can I "give back", anyway? We can only do with "our" "things" what He would want us to do.
  • Jeff
    Jeff, there is a difference between "giving" and "giving back." The things you described below are "giving." There are no strings attached...truly gifts. "Giving back" implies a debt of some sort. Not the same thing at all.
  • Reality or La la land?
    There comes a time in almost everyones life when a decision must be made. They either 1) have to come to the realization that they no longer live under Mommy and Daddy's roof and will need to go out into the world and earn a living or 2) they come to the realization that they are an adult but do not wish the burden of responsibility that goes with being an adult. Therefore they then seek out any other means in which they can beg, borrow or steal from the "fortunate ones", usually government accomplishes this task for them, in order so that they don't have to work or work as hard. Now if giving back means that I have to prop up a system that gives to the "less fortunate" and takes from the "fortunate"? I would rather burn my fortune in the burn barrell behind my house :)
  • Giving
    The First Lady just wants everyone to follow your example of all the money that you "gave back" when you donated your FairTax Book royalties to...um...well, uh-what was that charity you gave all that money to, Neal?
  • Copyleft:
    "Giving back to the community that has made your personal success possible..."

    Sorry, pardner, but the community did not make my personal success possible. I made it possible by:
    * Holding a part time or full time job since I was 14
    * Studying my butt off in high school to maintain above a 3.00 GPA
    * Starting my own small business
    * Studying even harder to graduate college...while working either full time or part time to afford school
    * Taking a year off from said college in order to work to afford the subsequent two years
    * Spending 23 years in the military and retiring
    * Staying married to the same woman for 22 years
    * Raising my kids to be good citizens, strong individuals, and hard workers.
    * Starting a consulting business
    * Working 10-14 hours a day on a routine basis to keep my business working.

    ...nope, no community made my successes (and some failures) possible...it was all on me.
  • Michelle Obama is apparently unaware...
    Of all the school nights I worked until 11:30pm... Of all the 14-16 hour days I put in during grad school... Of all the nights I spent on the couch in my student office or in the grad student lounge... Of all the hours of prep to pass my qualifying exams, prelims and doctoral defence... of all the years I worked my tail off to pay off those student loans amd save some $$$. Naw. Anything I have now is a "gift". MY FREKLED WHITE ARSE IT IS!!

    I'll "give" to things I believe in. But as Neal points out, it's "giving", NOT "giving back". (Goes for you too, Jeff)

    Seriously, Michelle Obama creeps the h*ll outta me.
  • MO
    Simply stated. She makes me puke. Therefore, in turn, I give back.
  • To the previous comment
    Neal's definition of giving back is giving by choice. The liberal's definition of giving back is by paying what the government says you should pay because of fairness.
  • to the previous comment
    Neal's definition of giving back is giving by choice. The liberal's definition of giving back is by paying what the government says you should pay because of fairness.
  • Commencement
    I was privileged enough to attend the Va. Tech graduation this past weekend. The commencement speech was delivered by Air Force General Lance L. Smith. I wish I could find a transcript but the best i could find on a quick search was this:

    http://www.timesdispatch.com/rtd/news/state_regional/article/GRAD17_20090516-220017/268220/

    I can tell you it was exactly the opposite of Mrs. Obama's.

    By the way, kudos to my friend Brian who graduated. He pushed himself so hard he finished his Bachelors in Mechanical Engineering in two years instead of four!
  • @ Jeff
    I think what you are trying to call "Giving Back" by Neal is just plain and simple "Giving".

    "Giving Back" means that you were given to in the first place. Angel flight has not given anything to Neal, therefore "Giving Back" is preposterous.
  • Giving back
    Most of the problems in this country are caused by giving while on someones back. That is why there are so many children below the poverty level because people below the poverty level pop them out on a regular basis to get more money. We are not replacing workers we are replacing shrikers. Workers can't afford to have kids of their own because of what they're paying to give back to the deadbeats. Michelle should tell these people to get off their duffs and get out and give back. I notice she only says that to people who have the possibility of actually accomplishing something on their own.
  • Knew it was Nonsense
    So glad to have you on my side - I knew my parents were full of it telling me everything I had was a gift from God and it was my responsibility to honor His gifts to me by helping others not as fortunate. I always knew it was just me and me alone - HOORAY FOR ME!!!!!
  • Now that we are on the National level
    Ever look up the numbers on Barack and Michelle's charitable giving "back" before he was on the National stage? Less than 1% of his income. It wasn't until his political aspirations were focused on the Presidency that they actually gave anything of significance. I make less than Barack was and I was still giving more (in terms of dollars, not just percent) than he and Michelle. He and his wife are frauds!!
  • Give Back
    What the hell has this woman done to be out on the speech circuit.

    She needs to get the hell back on the Pancake box.
  • Words mean things:
    "The less fortunate"; "Give back"; "Fair share"; "Equality (of outcome)."

    The Left has 'Orwellian-ized' much of our language for their political power.

    Bravo to Neal for frequently deflating the Left's 'community based reality', with a sharp dose of Boortz reality.
  • Stories to tell
    People who loathe the term "giving back" have a story to tell. It's about how they got where they are right now. These are long stories, full of emotions, attitudes, and trials that were endured and survived. People who embrace this stupid term don't have that story to tell yet.
    "Give back" DOES NOT EQUAL "Give"
  • LOOK UP
    Yeah Neal, it is only the Left that gives back. You are doing a fake commencement speech at a GOVERNMENT SCHOOL and will be giving back to charity. Not to mention, it is sold up and the article above this one is asking people to give money back. Just like republicans, they say things like lesser taxes and government, but it comes out the opposite
  • What do you expect?
    She was given a high paying makework administrative position at a university hospital(and we wonder where to cut health care costs), a promotion with a 250% raise, to a position that went away when she did. Her husband made a living dividing somebody else's wealth and doling it out to people who didn't earn it(I'm sure all that money did wonders to improve Chigago).

    In her experience, people ARE given what they don't earn. Too bad they almost never practice what they always preach.
  • To: Jeff in Dayton
    Your reading comprehension skills are lacking.
    Neal never said he doesn't "GIVE"...
    He is talking about the phrase "Giving BACK".
    Re-read and re-comment. It's obvious you are defending Neal. You're right about him "Giving" to a lot of worthy causes. Since he was not given something by these charitable organizations he was "Giving" - not "Giving Back".
    He is however, as you so kindly pointed out very helpful to many charities.
  • Only one party to "give back" to.
    I too am sick of this liberal phrase. From my perspective, there is only one party in which humans can give back, and that is God. Everything we are and have came from God, so the only party we can truly give back to is God, the rest are just gifts to those of us on this earth. I give gifts to people and organizations as I earned what I have by the grace of God. I cannot give anything back to people or groups as I did not get if from them in the beginning. Why cannot Libs understand the concept?
  • She and her husband have the "taking" part down pat
    perhaps they should follow their own advice and learn about the "giving" part. That's rich, kind of like her idiot husband blathering on last week about "unsustainable" levels of spending in Washington.

    They both earn an "H" for Hypocrite.
  • this story and trackbacks
    This is one of my peeves as well. Good rant by Neal.

    Now if I couold only figger out how to properly do a trackback. I'm linking this story in my column tonight in the Townhall blogs (http://constitutionalcrawfish.blogtownhall.com for anyone interested) but don't know how to properly make it trackback.
  • "Give Back?"
    How are these kids going to "give back" when they and their children will have nothing but debt courtesy of the current administration?
  • Give Back
    I honestly don't see the issue here. Even if m. obama thinks the students were handed everything on a silver platter....it is still a good idea to give back in some way to your community. I do find it interesting that studies show conservatives actually walk the walk when it comes to giving, and liberals just talk the talk, haha.
  • Copy
    Most times I ignore your moronic posts but let me get something straight here - YOU do not speak for me or the "majority" so quit trying to sound like you are pointing out obvious things that everyone other than Neal can see.

    No one in America "lucked out"--been GIVEN-- Anything that our forefathers didn't die fighting to provide. Or that our soldiers today still are fighting and dying to protect.

    If your stupid point was true then citizens in countries where everything is paid for (out of taxes but that doesn't bother you) then THEY would be the fortunate ones, not Americans who have had to work for what we have. Except for people like you that steal it from us.

    It is up to each of us individually to decide how charitable we want to be. Not you.
  • I had the same feelings Boortz
    However, let's advance the conservative position a bit more. The premise of giving back is a bit antithetical to the Democrats of the 60's. i.e. " ask not what your country can to for you, but what you can do for your country"

    Let's break that statement into 2 parts. The first says not to be selfish, and ask for things from the country. These would be the people that Michelle say's we should give to. Instead of giving them something, we should get them to ask "what can I do for myself?" note: Katrina "victims" living in free trailers for 4 years would be a start. Hell, they could have EARNED a college degree in less time.

    The second phrase, "what can you for your country?" I have an idea, go out there and be selfish, start a Company and earn as much money as is humanly possible. In the process of your fulfilling your desires, you will also employ hundreds, maybe thousands of people. That is the best way of giving back, rather than creating a societal class that depends on hand-outs.
  • Come On Neal
    I have to call B.S. on this one! You don't believe in "Giving Back"?? That's bull and you know it.

    Let's see there is Angle Flight, there is the Merry Christmas Marine, there is the thing at the children's hospital, ect., that you talk about on the air. We all know you are a private person, so we don't know about all the other good things you have done to "give back" to the things that are important to you. Such as Texas A&M, the Atlanta area, our military men and women, and the many other things you do that only your family and those nearest and dearest to you know. You can fool most of the dumb masses that are adding their posts, but those of us that really listen to you know you believe in giving back to those things that helped you in the past, in the hope that it will help someone else in the future.
  • Big Brother Says "GIVE BACK"
    So we have Mr. Obama, Mrs. Obama and Rham (I'm sure there are other admin officials speaking around the country too) all telling graduates to SACRIFICE, GIVE BACK, SERVE and not to get caught up in "MAKING MONEY" and "GREED".

    I"m sure all of their parents who spent the last 4+ years paying hundreds of thousands of dollars so little johnny could amount to something are ecstatic about the possibility that their little angle will go be a social worker being paid out of the government (taxpayers) coffers.

    Liberals think SERVING and GIVING BACK in the military is such a bad thing (ref John Kerry, "without a college degree you will end up in the military") but doing the same in an inner city thug school is great? The common denominator there is both positions are part of the federal government.

    Liberals simply SUCK.
  • "Give Back"
    Boooortzz!

    I was eating breakfast. I believe I did, in fact, just, "give something back".
  • Give back?
    I got little help from the 'community' growing up. What exactly do I have to "give back"? It sounds noble, that 60's kind of 'ask not...blah blah blah..." Most people who are successful do a lot in the community already. How dare the First Lady try to shame people into the idea that they got where they are because the 'community' helped them get there. No Ma'am, the individual did the work, put in the hours, kept focused and achieved. This isn't a collective farm. We are a nation of free individuals and everyone has the opportunity to succeed or fail on their own merit. And when it comes to choosing what and where and how to give something to the community, we can do that for ourselves, thank you! And all the 'progressives' need to get over this idea that they are 'holier than thou', that same attitude got Republicans in trouble and opened the door for a win by default.
  • I get sick of hearing this one, too.
    But, it's not just polititians. I had a boss to say when asking for concessions, "You've been with the company for 15 years look at what all it's given you, now you need to give a little back." I earned every dime at made at that company. At the time, I was $15,000/yr under market for my position.
    I have to say, it was very motivating. I put my resume out and within 3 weeks, I had a job making about $20k more than I was. So, I guess I did give back, I gave them their job back.

    I think what's galling about a pol calling for giving back, is that they are the ones that are always taking. Sure they call themselves public servents, but they're always paid and the benefits always outweight any service they render.
  • Wrong Speech
    Michelle's speech would've been a good one for a UAW event.
  • Follow the example
    If I follow the example set by the Obamas, I can cut back on my giving back this year. Their tax return showed they gave 1% of their income to charity. Think I'll do as they do, not as they say.
  • Good point
    As Neal so aptly pointed out..."Give back" is not the same as "give"

    Wonder how long it will be before they change that phrasing?
  • oh, the irony
    Isn't it funny how the Biden family and Obama family had little to nothing in the way of charitable giving... until a handful in the media pointed out that little inconvenient fact. The tax records are out there - look it up yourself.
  • Give back
    I agree 100% Neal. How about "pay it forward". Giving back would be paying back my mortgage...they gave it to me to buy the house & I am giving it back.
  • And Rand tried to claim selfishness was a virtue...
    Didn't make it true, though. Giving back to the community that has made your personal success possible is still a valid and moral concept, no matter how hard libertarians try to wish it away.

    And yes, Neal, you're alone. Everyone born in the 20th century in the United States has already "lucked out"--been GIVEN--enormous advantages that the rest of the world, and most of human history, could only dream of. And they didn't do a single thing to earn those advantages.

    What you do with your life is, of course, up to you. But pretending you owe all your success (if any) SOLELY to your own hard work is specious nonsense. It appeals to the selfish urges that most of us outgrow in our teen years as we struggle to evolve an actual sense of ethics and morality.

    Boy, remember back when conservatives claimed to have values? Other than "I got mine, screw you," that is.... (snicker)
  • Trash
    I knew white trash. They were my inlaws. They get together and teach each other the rules, and brag about their victories.
    One day my ex-sister-in-law looked at her youngest of two illegitimate, unknown father kids and said, "It's about time to have another kid. The money's running out on him." Three months later she was pregnant, and pretended to have no idea who the babydaddy was.
    Two of her brothers were professional work-till-unemployment-is-locked-in guys who would get fired on purpose to drink and smoke weed. Two others were real good at working, and stealing off the jobs they did. The wife drove busses, but stole my paychecks for several years before I decided to get back to my culture.
    It's difficult for people who were raised to work hard and not lie, cheat, or steal to understand that there are people who were raised by trash to become trash. Skin color was never the issue.
    Welfare for those truly in need would be wonderful. Lazy thieves ruined it.
  • THE ONLY ONES
    that require 'giving back' are those that 'took' in the first place.
    Liberals don't understand that.
  • Get your hands of my stack
    Hey, Benevolent Imperial Government, how about ‘giving back’ some of my earnings that you seized from me at the point of a B.I.G. gun?
  • I feel like Miss Daisy
    Every time I hear someone saying we should give back, I feel like Miss Daisy; I think I am going to spit up. Let's see how I became more fortunate. I worked a full time job, a part time job and went to college at the same time. I paid my own way, bought less than I could afford, and had kids when I could afford them. That is, I suppose, being given something that I should give back.
  • Give back and make a difference
    The two most tired misleading phrases in popular use today.

    The biggest, most effective and efficient way to do either is to use the freedom and opportunity you have to be productive. When you make a product that is useful, someone buys it and is happy because it feels a need, you both give and get back something. In the meantime, you also make a difference.
  • THE TRICK
    is to realize that it's not your money.

    IRS Auditor
  • For an example, see Hypo Detector's post
    They don't get it. Yeah we're all for charities-voluntary. Explain to me, Hypocrisy Detector, how do I give back something I never received?

    I "give" of myself, my time, my money. Those receiving from me, can give back to me, by becoming more self-sufficient.
  • You're not alone Neal,
    There was a time when Americans gave plenty to charity. And for the most part we still do, but now we have plenty TAKEN from us and redistributed as the government sees fit, not as we would give. To make matters worse, there is mass fraud in the government charity's.

    I know many others who feel the same. I still give (I never "give back") to charity, but not as much as if I were allowed to keep more of what I earn. But the government doesn't want ME deciding who gets MY money. Because when the same people came back for the third or fourth hand out they'd be put to work doing something or turned away. Just like in the old days when they were called hobos, not homeless. And there were a lot fewer then because people wouldn't put up with it. Today government encourages it with your and my money.
  • Give Back Nonsense
    I constantly argue with my friends over this. Most of them won't argue back. I just get blank stares. It wasn't given to me. It's my hard earned money; I can burn it and take a leak on it if I want to.
  • ejmoosa@yahoo.com
    As if 1 of every 4 years they work in the future, which goes to taxes, is not giving back enough.
  • Pure hyocrisy
    Conservatives love to go on and on about the innate generosity of the American people; advocating for a role of charities instead of government. Conservatives even like to gloat about the fact that they donate more to charity than liberals (thogh my suspicion is if you took donations to churches out of the equation, this would not be true).

    But now Bortz poo-poos the idea of college graduates giving back.

    So, OK, college graduates, never give a dime to your alumni foundation; let the taxpayers provide 100% of the funding of your alma mater instead.
  • Here's how to give back...
    Go out and be successful. Be spectacularly successful! Earn lots of money and buy a nice home. That "free" primary education you received was made possible through property taxes... richer people paid more for your education, so get rich and help the next generation along.
  • MICHELLE SAYS TO GIVE BACK.
    You're not the only one whose tired of that insipid phrase!
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
advertisement