Just make these losers disappear. They won't be missed.

My question is, how do we know they returned to terrorism? Did we recapture them? Kill them on the field? If we're monitoring them, and know they are participating in terrorist activities, why have we not captured them or those around them? Could it be that we're monitoring them for intelligence reasons, thereby serving our own interests? We need more details before we can reasonably swallow the spin from the right on this....

And as for Gitmo, I say lets put them all on a small island in Alaska, far from anyone who cares. If you're concerned about said island being American soil, we can renounce said island as our territory, and let another country claim them, or sell it to the UN.

Dick Cheney has been on the War Path for the last month trying to stop Obama from shutting down Gitmo. The question is why? Cheney does not care about the American people otherwise he would not have been on board with those whom sent over a thousand of our Soldiers in to a country needlesssly to search for WMD's that do not exist, yell Mission Accomplished and continue to fight. Remind me again when you say Mission Accomplished doesn't that mean the fight is over. Dick Cheney is trying to hide something from the American people. For all of those scared conservatives out there with extremely narrow minded views "ITS OKAY TO BE DIFFERENT." You Neo-Facists need to realize not everyone can be a white christian from Leave it to Beaver Land. I mean a lot has to be said when the best face of the Republican party right now is Rush Limbaugh. Did anyone else remember HE WAS A DROPOUT WHO BARELY GRADUATED HIGH SCHOOL.

Yes, it does include them.

They were likely released due to pressure from groups like the ACLU who defend Muslim terrorists. The people incarcerated at Gitmo were NOT put there for jaywalking or driving with a suspended license.

So what if they were not caught in the act of committing the next great terrorist atrocity? Prevention is a useful tool, one people on the left find highly offensive for some reason (such as preemptive strikes and violence of action).

"Copyleft, the proof is that they were captured by our soldiers trying to destroy personnel and materiel. Call them insurgents if you want, they are the enemy no matter what you say."

Really? Does that include the ones that have already been released? Should we go back up and round them up because they "must have done something, or they wouldn't have been there"?

It looked pretty big.

Several things make me sick about this issue.

Copyleft, the proof is that they were captured by our soldiers trying to destroy personnel and materiel. Call them insurgents if you want, they are the enemy no matter what you say. My brother's unit is responsible for the capture of more than 10 of those detainees.

t-shirt doctor, i find it hard to accept that these guys were sitting around in their dirt huts with nothing but love for america until our soldiers arrived. suddenly they are terrorists? it's more deeply-seated and religiously motivated than that.

Lastly, could Obama have picked a worse day to try to close this institution (Gitmo) than a day when 4 would-be Muslim terrorists were caught with plans to attack synagogues n NYC?

It's becoming unreal the way liberals view the world. People who read the Bible and do not support gay marriage are the only dangerous people left on the planet. Which religion calls for the stoning of gay people again..?

Tell you what, they can bring them onto US soil only if they put into the max security prison under the watchful eye of Sheriff Joe in Maricopa AZ and give him free reign to deal with them any way he pleases. A no nonsense guy like him should solve that problem

I have an idea of where to release the orange suiters in GTMO. Put them in Illinois, Hawaii, Connecticut, California and Massachusetts. These are the quasi home states of Obama, Chris Dodd, Barney Frank, Nancy Pelosi, and Barbara Boxer. If Copyleft would leave what state he is from, we should release them to his states as well.

Copyleft is evidently treating this war on terror as criminal justice matter instead of an act of war. He wants to apply US Justice Statues to Acts of War. If he would remember that was the Clinton Strategy in the 1990's and we had the TWA shot down in 1996 and September 11,2001.

This type of naivete will have the US praying to Mecca five times a day and will get people on the left silenced by Shariah law.

My Father-in-Law thinks that the prisoners at Guantanamo Bay should be used to perform groundskeeping duties at Camp David.

We've learned before that these numbers need to be taken with a gain of salt. Some of the guys they've counted as "returning" to terrorism weren't terrorists before but became after year of incarceration and mistreatment. Others were detained again, but it wasn't clear that they were engaged in terrorism. A few were even counted as "returning to terrorism" when it turned out they were fighting on our side.

I'll wait until the full report is out and all the names are released before I start screaming blue murder.

well, when the terrorists return home, the US soldiers are still there. of course they'll return to terrorism. i would do the same thing, if foreign troops invaded my country.
they are terrorists because we're over there, interfering with stuff that ain't none of our business.

Or, if you're so certain these detainees are terrorists, why can't you produce enough evidence (or ANY evidence) to actually prove it?