advertisement

The world-famous Internet site of the Nationally Syndicated Neal Boortz Show!

Search Boortz.com
Enter search terms:
Browse Boortz.com
Today's Nuze

"Every government interference in the economy consists of giving an unearned benefit, extorted by force, to some men at the expense of others."

Ayn Rand

Nobody's listening.

THE CRAMDOWN BILL

By
Neal Boortz
@ February 24, 2009 9:11 AM
Permalink | Comments (20) | TrackBacks (0)

This week we are going to see this "cramdown" bill come up for debate. We are probably talking Thursday. But this is the bill that would allow judges to erase or reduce the principal amount of a mortgage for borrowers who file for bankruptcy. In other words ... you buy a house for $225,000. You borrow $200,000 from a third party (individual, bank, mortgage lender .. whatever) to give to the person who sold you the house, along with $25,000 of your own. The third party lender takes a security interest in your home to cover any losses in case you fail to pay them back. Then you go deadbeat and file bankruptcy. The judge then rules that you don't have to pay all of the $200,000 you borrowed from the third party back ... and what's more, the third party cannot rely on their security interest in your home to make themselves whole. Pretty nifty, huh?

Now ... how will the mortgage lenders react to this? Do you know what PMI is? That's private mortgage insurance. When you don't put enough money down on your home the lender may make you pay premiums for PMI. This insurance policy will pay off the lender if you bail on your loan, the lender forecloses, and you home doesn't bring enough at auction to cover the amount you still own the lender. People don't much like paying PMI ... but it has been part of the game if you put less than 20% of the purchase price down. Well, let me introduce you to a derivative of PMI. This may be called PBI. Private bankruptcy insurance. This will be an insurance policy that the lender will take out to cover them in case you go bankrupt and the judge says that you can keep your home and you don't have to pay all of the loan back. Guess who is going to pay the premium for this insurance? That would be you .. another little goodie added to your mortgage payment. Add 'em up. A nice fat little extra added to your monthly payment to cover the lender if they foreclose on you and don't get enough at foreclosure to cover the amount you still owe, and another fat little extra added to your monthly payment for insurance to protect the lender in case you go bankrupt and the judge reduces the balance you owe and lets you keep the house. Either way ... borrowers who fully intend to pay their mortgage and have little likelihood of going bankrupt are going to have to cover part of the tab for the deadbeats out there.

There is another possibility. Maybe the government will make PBI illegal. Then the lenders just hike the interest rates to cover the potential losses from these cramdown provisions. Who knows! Maybe they'll create PBI and hike the interest rates as well! Or maybe they'll just tighten up the credit requirements to the point that if you even give a hint of the smell of someone who might someday go bankrupt you won't be able to get a loan. How could you emit this odor? Credit card balances, instable job history, too much available credit ... there are many ways.

Seems like a good time to be looking into owning apartments and rental homes again.



0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: THE CRAMDOWN BILL.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://boortz.com/blogging/mt-tb.cgi/22453

Jamie Dupree's Blog

If you enjoy Neal's daily chat with Jamie Dupree, you'll love Jamie's Blog! Check it out for analysis of the campaigns and goings on in Washington D.C.

Take Back Our Government!

Herman Cain is putting together a movement to take back our government. Do something now! Join the Hermanator's Intelligent Thinkers Movement, HITM! , and take part in the political revolution of 2009! "When they feel the heat, they will see the light!"

Belinda Skelton, Cristina Gonzalez and Laura Nunemaker assist in the daily preparation of Nealz Nuze!


Avg. rating: N/A

What others are saying

  • Cram Down Expectations
    "Seems like a good time to be looking into owning apartments and rental homes again."

    Neal, You are critical about allowing BK judges to modify primary mortgages for the middle class yet for the last 20 years, a judge could do exactly that on those apartment buildings you mention above, private jets, vacation homes, luxury cars and almost anything but a mortgage on a primary residence.
    Are you just upset that the middle class may get some of the benefits available to the rich?
  • Cramdown?
    What happens when the property increases in value and is sold. Does the debtor get to keep his equity from the written down loan? If net worth is equated to assets minus liabilities, and a judge has adjusted this deadbeats liabilities, he has artificially increased his net worth. Isn't this just a backdoor redistribution of wealth?
  • Cramdown?
    What happens when the deadbeat sells the property for more than the newly adjusted mortgage? Can he keep the capital gain? If net worth is assets minus liabilities, isn't arbritrary lowering liabilities going to increase net worth? Isn't this backdoor redistribution of wealth?
  • Sure now it is Banks accepting lower payments
    Why is it only possible to go one way ? We just added a bazillion dollars to the debt. Soon the inflationary pressure will come into play. Will a judge be able to adjust your mgtg to match inflation ? If this passes why not ? Debt free is the only way to be. I am not there yet but I am working towards it.
  • PMI/PBI
    So SDN has no education - no economics 101. Too bad. Learn responsibility.
  • PMI/PBI
    Don't forget the amount of the loan reduced will be added to the borrowers income tax, perhaps as capital gains. Obama wants to raise the capital gains tax. Do the math.
  • PMI/PBI
    If you read David Johnston's "Free Lunch", you'll realize what a total scam PMI is. I'm sure PBI will create another batch of billionaires on the back of us working shlubs...
  • Not so fast, comrade Boortz
    What is this turn-down for bad credit you speak of? This person is member of Official Victim Group. Automatic credit score of 800. Otherwise, we will send the AcornJugend by to "reason" with your family, and of course your business license might not get renewed....

    Oh, is Person of Straight Pallor? No problem; the dirty swine just wants to leech off the Faithful.
  • Cram It!
    I don't understand the cramdown at all. If the banks is going to lose all the money they put into the mortgage anyway, why not just foreclose and sell it to someone fiscally responsible for the same price.

    This is based on the idea that foreclosures drive down home prices. But that crosses me as nonsense. *Empty homes* drive down home prices.
  • Cramdown
    Neal makes a good point here. I have been confused for weeks why lenders haven't been able to reach for PMI funds to offset the losses they're taking on mortgages they are forclosing?

    I hate paying PMI, but bought without a full 20% down, and am okay with it considering my situation when I bought. I am not okay with paying PMI and then seeing lenders seeking additional funds from our government to offset their losses from loans that should have PMI to augment them (TARP program) and then our government require judges to reduce the principal on loans in the latest advent of socialism when PMI should already be present to assist the lenders and homeowners emerge from ugly situations.

    Maybe I don't fully understand PMI, and if someone (not the government) could educate me I would be greatly appreciative.
  • John Galt?
    John Galt could NEVER get elected in today's America. I doubt J.F. Kennedy could either - you know, with all that "ask not what your country can do for you" crap. Sadly, no politician could get elected while running on a platform of Self-Reliance. I hate to be a defeatist, but Obama is not the problem; he's a symptom of the problem.
  • House Crisis....I'm confused....
    I have recently heard a couple of percentages of people who are paying their mortgages (either 92 or 94 percent). So this SO-CALLED crisis is over either 6 or 8 percentage of bad mortgages. Yeah right! The other thing was that the majority of these mortgages were mostly in 5 states. Now no surprise here...Nevada and California were two of the states...hmmmm Pelosi and Reed represent which states?

    Since we are putting requirements on companies who take taxpayer money, can we also put requirements on people who take taxpayer money - like no Cell phones, No cable TV, No New Car, No Credit Cards...hey only trying to cut their expenses so they can afford their mortgage payments.

    Just my 2 cents...Since that is all the Imperial Government will leave me.
  • Cramdown
    Neal

    Dont forget that after this is in effect, and lenders start carefully screening who they make loans to - the hue and cry of "redlining" and not lending to certain high risk groups. Then the Govt steps in and tells these banks you MUST lend to these neighborhoods. And the hits just keep on coming!!
  • Cramdown bill
    Reliance is one of those features of rule of law that a free society really needs. This is a disaster. This man is a disaster. This man threatens to destroy every shred of freedom and capitalism that built America.

    As a lender, been in the game for the last 20 years, if you can't rely on asset recovery and sale...expect the conditions for lending to tighten incredibly. Forget 10-20% down loans... expect at least 30-50% minimum down payment requirements and the debt ratio requirements to tighten significantly.

    If you can't foreclose and sell the asset, then folks are going to find it incredibly hard to own a home.

    Of course, if history is any indicator...with any tyrant or dictator...you have to watch the other hand and not the one they are showing you.

    If the goal is for government takeover of every aspect of your life (and we're going there on greased skids) then the goal is to make every competitor of government something that is unattainable so that government has no choice, but out of benevolence and love of the people, to take it over and make it possible for you, the little guy.

    (puke).. We're headed for a place we never imagined in our worst nightmares.
  • PBI and economic opportunity
    I have no problem with lenders charging PBI if the USSA (United Socialist States of America) states that lenders can't go after what remedies they need to make them whole if someone does not pay their mortgage. However, Neal you do make a point that after all the smoke clears there will be a definite market for rental housing as these measures will make credit even tighter.
  • Cramdown
    Talking heads wonder why the bank stocks are in the tank. Could it be the rational fear that:

    1. The banks may be nationalized and you loose your capital in the valueless shares you hold.

    2. The banks loose shareholder capital in the write down of the looser mortgages they hold, and the cleaning off of the bones by attorneys in a class action lawsuit.

    3. Need to raise additional capital to meet "reserve Requirements" of the regulators to cover the loss of value by the cramdowns. Only Uncle Sam will be bellying up tp that bar ( see #1 above)

    4. All of the above.

    Change we can all beleive in!
  • Housing
    This is my gut reaction. Whatever the outcome once I pay off my house i will make every effort to buy my next house CASH.

    I'm sure there are many out there that can do that now.

    It's absolutely amazing, the people wanted change, but I'm sure that this is not the change they wanted.

    Maybe someone in congress isn't in a drunken stuper will come up with a law as long as you are getting welfare, you can't vote in a Big Boy election.

    Yeah, whack-jobs, say what you will but this is the way we should go to make a major correction with our problems.
  • Ayn Rand
    Atlas Shrugged should be required reading in the halls of Washington today.
    "I swear by my life...and my love of it....that I will never live for the sake of another man...nor ask another man...to live...for mone."
    - John Galt in Atlas Shrugged
  • Once again
    The people that pay their bills wind up paying for those who do not.
  • Oh NO! I've done it ALL WRONG!
    I pay all my bills on time, paid off the car loan, paid off the truck loan, paid off the mortgage, paid off the student loans and now the gubmint sez I don't have to. Well screw me. And the increased costs for the parasites that'll take full advantage get passed on to ... little ole me. BOHICA! (Bend Over, Here It Comes Again) - I didn't enjoy it the first time, the next time won't be any better.
send to a friend  view as printer-friendly  RSS feeds
advertisement
advertisement
advertisement